Angie Archibald
Traditional brick townhomes overlooking a green lawn and autumn landscaping in a quiet James City County neighborhood.

Reading James City County's September Price Drop Before You Make an Offer

James City County's median sale price fell 18.1% from September 2025 to September 2026, from $535,000 to $438,368. The same Williamsburg Area Association of Realtors report puts the county's year-to-date median through September at $484,950. A year earlier it was $485,000. That works out to fifty dollars of change over nine months of sales.

If you're comparing Toano, Ford's Colony, Kingsmill and the City this winter, keep both numbers in front of you. The September figure tells you something real about James City County, but not that houses got 18% cheaper. Most of the drop comes from which homes sold and from what last September looked like. The real change for a buyer right now is how many homes there are to choose from.

Two medians, one report

Here are the James City County figures from the WAAR Market Indicators Report for September 2026, built from Virginia REALTORS data pulled on October 15, 2026.

James City County 2025 2026 Change
September median, all homes $535,000 $438,368 -18.1%
Jan.–Sept. median, all homes $485,000 $484,950 0.0%
September median, single-family $597,000 $477,895 -20.0%
Jan.–Sept. median, single-family $535,000 $525,000 -1.9%
September median, townhome and condo $374,000 $379,495 +1.5%
September sales, all homes 133 156 +17.3%

Look at the bottom row first. If prices in James City County had really dropped by a fifth, you'd expect a market where sellers are pulling back. September went the other way, with 23 more closings than the year before. WAAR says it was the seventh straight month of year-over-year sales gains in the county.

Last September ran hot

A year-over-year comparison is only as steady as the month you're comparing against. In September 2025, the county's all-homes median was $535,000, about 10% above the $485,000 median for January through September of that year. The single-family median that month was $597,000, while the nine-month single-family median was $535,000.

So September 2025 had an unusually expensive group of closings. September 2026 landed roughly as far below its own nine-month median as last year landed above. Put a high month next to a low month and you get a big percentage. Neither month is a fair picture of what a typical James City County house is worth.

The sample is small, too. James City County closed 110 single-family homes in September 2026. In a county where a waterfront estate in Kingsmill and a starter home near Toano land in the same pool, a handful of sales at either end can move that month's median by tens of thousands of dollars.

More townhomes closed this September

Part of the swing comes from the kind of home that closed. James City County sold 46 townhomes and condos in September 2026, up from 29 the year before, a 58.6% jump. That took attached homes from about 22% of the county's September sales to about 29%.

Townhomes cost less than detached houses here. The county's September townhome and condo median was $379,495, and the single-family median was $477,895. When a bigger share of sales comes from the lower-priced group, the overall median drops even if neither group got cheaper. In this case the townhome median actually rose 1.5% from a year earlier.

You can see this kind of inventory on the ground in Toano. Ryan Homes is building Stonehouse Townes, with the Nassau Cove plan listed from $309,990 and the Thornewood from $329,990. Nearby at 7030 Cunningham Drive, the builder's Stonehouse Ranch lists one-level homes from $369,990. Its gated 55+ community, Settlement at Powhatan, at 5000 Winding Creek, starts at $359,990. Those prices come from the builder's live pages and can change. They are well below the county's 2026 median of $484,950, and new homes priced in that range pull the median down as they close. For how the monthly costs of attached living compare here, see townhome vs. single-family costs in Williamsburg.

Price per square foot went up

A median only marks the middle sale, while price per square foot gets closer to what a buyer paid for the same amount of house. Across WAAR's whole footprint, which covers James City County, Williamsburg, York, New Kent and Charles City, the average price per square foot rose 6.3% from September 2025 to September 2026, from $215 to $229. For January through September it rose 2.8%, from $219 to $226. That figure covers the whole region, not James City County alone. It still points away from the idea that a given house got cheaper.

Sellers in the region also held close to their asking prices. Homes across the WAAR footprint sold for an average of 99.3% of asking in September 2026, up from 98.4% a year earlier.

What changed: how many homes you can choose from

The shift that matters for your offer is supply. James City County ended September 2026 with 540 active listings, up 24.1% from 435 a year earlier. Months of supply rose from 3.3 to 4.0, and new listings rose 13.1% to 199 for the month. Townhomes and condos grew fastest. Active attached listings went from 84 to 130, and months of supply in that segment rose from 2.8 to 4.5.

Demand cooled in September. Pending sales in James City County fell 22.3% year over year, 31 fewer contracts, and WAAR tied the region-wide drop in pending sales to rising mortgage rates. The rate tracker in that report shows the 30-year fixed at 7.40%. Fewer new contracts against more listings is the setting buyers will step into this winter.

The newest regional read is REIN's October 2026 release for Hampton Roads, dated Nov. 10, which reports region-wide figures and shows the same pattern: 6,603 active listings, up 18.5% from October 2025, and 3.11 months of supply, up from 2.68. REIN connects the slowdown to the holidays and to higher household costs and mortgage rates.

Reading a James City County listing this winter

Here's how I'd use all this when you're looking at houses around Thanksgiving. Don't go into a Ford's Colony showing expecting 18% off last year's price, because nothing in the yearly or per-square-foot numbers backs that up. What the market does give you is time and options. With four months of supply countywide and four and a half for townhomes, more of the homes you tour will have been listed for a while. More sellers will also have a competing listing down the street, and that's where you have room to ask for repairs, closing help or a better price.

Compare like with like, too. A Toano townhome and a Kingsmill single-family house share a county median and almost nothing else. Look at the year-to-date median for the type of home you want, and look at recent sales in that particular community. If you're weighing parts of the county, the Greater Williamsburg / JCC page and the Toano neighborhood page are good places to start.

A couple of quick questions

Did the City of Williamsburg see the same drop? The City's September median fell 25%, to $285,000, but on only 16 sales, which is too few to tell much from one month. Its January-through-September median was $374,000, down 7.5% from the same stretch of 2025.

I own a home in James City County. Is it worth 18% less? The county figures that cover longer stretches say no. The single-family median for January through September is down 1.9%, and regional price per square foot is up. What your own home is worth comes from the sales around it.

If the September headline made you wonder what your James City County home would sell for, or what you could negotiate on the townhome you've been eyeing, let's look at the real comps for your street together. Start with a free home valuation, or reach out to Angie Archibald and let's make your big move.

Let’s Find Your Dream Home

Get assistance in determining the current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram